Umar Amin looks like a classy batsman. Anyone who's seen him bat will admit that he looks like a gun player, and an excellent batsman. However, his international performances have shown he has major problems against swing and spin. That led me to dig into his domestic record. It does not make for good reading. He averages just over 38 in FC and around 32 in List A. This is not the type of player you select. He was selected on the basis of his T20 performances the first time around and he's shown that he's not a fit on the stage. Yes, he looks like a good, compact player but he's a horror against good quality bowling. Poor selection, and he should be replaced by Haris or Umar Akmal.